The University of Sheffield
Catchment Science Centre

Aquatic risks of pesticides, ecological protection goals, and common aims in european union legislation

Brock, TCM; Arts, GHP; Maltby, L.; Van den Brink, PJ (2006)

Aquatic risks of pesticides, ecological protection goals and common claims in EU legislation. Integrated Environmental Management and Protection, 2, e20-e46

Abstract

This discussion paper presents a framework for spatiotemporal differentiation in ecological protection goals to assess the risks of pesticides in surface waters. It also provides a proposal to harmonize the different scientific approaches for
ecotoxicological effect assessment adopted in guidance documents that support different legislative directives in the European Union (Water Framework Directive and Uniform Principles). Decision schemes to derive maximum permissible concentrations in surface water are presented. These schemes are based on approaches recommended in regulatory guidance documents and are scientifically underpinned by critical review papers concerning the impact of pesticides on freshwater organisms and communities. Special attention is given to the approaches based on standard test species, species sensitivity distribution curves, and model ecosystem experiments. The decision schemes presented here may play a role in the ``acceptability´´ debate and can be used as options in the process of communication between risk assessors and risk managers as well as between these risk experts and other stakeholders.

Key words

Plant protection products Freshwater ecosystems Ecological effect assessment Water Framework Directive 91/414/EEC

Figure 1. The domains of science, ethics, and aesthetics all play an important role in the perception of the ecological risks of toxicants and in the