Experts call for more active prevention of tooth decay for children’s teeth

  • Three-year trial comparing three treatment strategies for tooth decay in children’s teeth finds no evidence to suggest that conventional fillings are more successful than sealing decay into teeth, or using preventive methods alone
  • FiCTION is the largest study to date comparing options for treating children’s tooth decay, with 1,144 children, their parents, and 72 NHS dental clinics in the UK involved
  • 43 per cent of those participating in the study experienced toothache or dental infection regardless of the dental treatment received
  • All three different ways of treating decay were acceptable to children, parents and dental professionals

Image of a dental exam

A dentist’s drill might not be the best way to tackle tooth decay in children’s teeth, a new study has concluded.

Findings from a major dental trial suggest that preventing tooth decay from occurring in the first place is the most effective way for parents to help avoid pain and infection from decay in their children’s teeth.

A three-year study comparing three different treatment options for tooth decay in children’s teeth, led by dentists from the University of Sheffield School of Clinical Dentistry and the Universities of Dundee, Newcastle, Cardiff, Queen Mary University of London and Leeds, has found no evidence to suggest that conventional fillings are more effective in stopping pain and infection from tooth decay in primary teeth, than sealing decay into teeth, or using prevention techniques alone.

The FiCTION trial, the largest of its kind to date, also found that 450 children who took part in the study experienced tooth decay and pain, regardless of which kind of dental treatment they received.

During the study, more than 1,140 children between the ages of three and seven with visible tooth decay were recruited by dentists working in one of 72 dental clinics throughout the country. One of three treatment approaches was then chosen randomly for each child’s dental care for the duration of the trial, which was up to three years.

The first approach avoided placing any fillings and aimed to prevent new decay by reducing sugar intake, ensuring twice daily brushing with fluoridated toothpaste, application of fluoride varnish and placing of fissure sealants on the first permanent molar (back) teeth.

The second option involved drilling out tooth decay, which was based upon what has been considered the standard “drill and fill” practice for more than 50 years together with preventive treatments.

The third treatment strategy was a minimally invasive approach where tooth decay was sealed in under a metal crown or a filling to stop it progressing together with preventive treatments.

This study will improve the way we teach our dental students in Sheffield and our city-wide efforts to improve children's oral health.

Professor Chris Deery

Sealing-in with preventive treatment was most likely to be considered the best way of managing children’s tooth decay if society are willing to pay a minimum of £130 to avoid an episode of pain or infection.

Professor Zoe Marshman, Chair of dental public health at the University of Sheffield, said: "As part of this study the team in Sheffield interviewed children, parents and dental professionals about their views on the different ways of treating tooth decay. The key finding was the importance of trust that the right treatment for each child will be carried out in a child-centred way.

“The good news however is that tooth decay can be prevented in the first place by encouraging children to brush their teeth thoroughly twice a day with fluoride toothpaste, reducing sugar consumption and seeing a dentist regularly.”

Professor Nicola Innes, Chair of Paediatric Dentistry at the University of Dundee and lead author on the paper published today, said, “Our study shows that each way of treating decay worked to a similar level but that children who get tooth decay at a young age have a high chance of experiencing toothache and abscesses regardless of the way the dentist manages the decay.

“What is absolutely clear is that the best way to manage tooth decay is not by drilling it out or sealing it in - it’s by preventing it in the first place.”

Professor Chris Deery, Chair of Paediatric Dentistry at the University of Sheffield, said: "Tooth decay effects over one-third of children in Sheffield causing pain, sleepless nights and time missed from school. This study will improve the way we teach our dental students in Sheffield and our city-wide efforts to improve children's oral health.”

Study with the University of Sheffield School of Clinical Dentistry

Additional information

  • The FICTION study was funded by the Health Technology Assessment (HTA) programme of the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR).

The University of Sheffield

With almost 29,000 of the brightest students from over 140 countries, learning alongside over 1,200 of the best academics from across the globe, the University of Sheffield is one of the world’s leading universities.

A member of the UK’s prestigious Russell Group of leading research-led institutions, Sheffield offers world-class teaching and research excellence across a wide range of disciplines.

Unified by the power of discovery and understanding, staff and students at the university are committed to finding new ways to transform the world we live in.

Sheffield is the only university to feature in The Sunday Times 100 Best Not-For-Profit Organisations to Work For 2018 and for the last eight years has been ranked in the top five UK universities for Student Satisfaction by Times Higher Education.

Sheffield has six Nobel Prize winners among former staff and students and its alumni go on to hold positions of great responsibility and influence all over the world, making significant contributions in their chosen fields.

Global research partners and clients include Boeing, Rolls-Royce, Unilever, AstraZeneca, Glaxo SmithKline, Siemens and Airbus, as well as many UK and overseas government agencies and charitable foundations.


For more information, please contact:

Rebecca Ferguson
Media Relations Officer
0114 222 9859